You guys. This Cream Cheese Ice Cream. It’s like a little piece of heaven. With lots of peanut buttery candy. 

Difficulty: Level 1 (easy peasy)

Hands On Time: 5 minutes   Total Time: 1 hr 35 minutes

This Cream Cheese Ice Cream might be the favorite at our house. We love anything cream cheese. And we definitely love anything stuffed with Reese’s and Butterfingers! There actually is a story to how this ice cream was discovered. Basically…our date nights consist of big burritos, a good movie, a giant popcorn and it is almost always finished off with ice cream on the way home. Every time we got ice cream I chose a different combination, basically trying to find the best ice cream combination ever. One day I quickly ordered this combo and OMG…it totally changed my life. And now I order it all the time because I know there is nothing better. I couldn’t justify going to the ice cream store every day, so I figured out how to make it at home! Hence, this Cream Cheese Ice Cream (with Reese’s and Butterfingers!!) came to be. You are welcome. It will change your life too.

Cream Cheese Ice Cream
Cream Cheese Ice Cream
Cream Cheese Ice Cream


  1. OMG, ice cream made with cream cheese? I love cream cheese frosting, so I know I’m going to love this! We all really like the flavours that have bits of chocolate bars, fudge, caramel, toffee, etc., so this is the perfect recipe for my family.

Leave a Reply